Metallica, Potentially greatest band ever?

J

JarOfFlies

#4
Potentially, yes. Four awesome back-to-back albums, then they ruin it all with the black album.
 
T

The Borg

#5
no way. load, reload, st anger...terrible.

the black album was good but lyrics to sandman..you guessed it terrible
 

evilmittens

Kill, Maim, Purge!
Premium
Mar 16, 2005
12,879
296
0
Next to you.
#7
I still have Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets on records :eek:
I think the early stuff was great, up thorugh the Black Alubum..

Load/re-load are ok for rock albums BUT not a great CD for Metallica..
St Anger sucked donkey balls.

Garage Inc...disk 2 was remiencent of their past..disk one sucked monkey ass.
 

Liquid Tension

THE ATHEISTS NIGHTMARE!
Dec 12, 2004
856
8
0
#8
I dont like their style of metal. It really isnt creative and doesnt really "rock" for me. I know for other people this isnt the case, but for me its a personal call.
 
J

JarOfFlies

#16
Stupified said:
I think Black Album was their last decent album.
I liked it, but I didn't like it as a Metallica album.

If that makes sense?

It's a good album, as a rock album, but when you compare it to their previous four it is shit.
 
H

HydeBlitz

#17
The Borg said:
no way. load, reload, st anger...terrible.

the black album was good but lyrics to sandman..you guessed it terrible

load was good reload garage inc and saint anger aren;t metallica I think if metallica didnt make those and they didn't atatck napster then those 3 albums would be more popular

garage inc does have some great cover son it but how about somethign new?
 
Mar 20, 2005
485
14
0
#18
what the fuck, metalica is not the best band ever at all.

Firstly you need to check out good metal, like dragonforce for instance, they are just plain good.
Great guitar drums bass piano vocals.

Helloween, same thing.

Dream theatre.

Check them out.

Metalicca is NOTHING compared to these guys.
 
Last edited: